Talk:Just Dance 2018/@comment-27537247-20180302161148/@comment-1465604-20180309175017

While Chemiql2 is just wrong, wrong, wrong about Beyoncé not being a great live vocalist, the "You have no right to criticize someone unless you can do what they can do better" argument is an invalid argument. Someone can have a better grasp of the craft and the techniques involved, yet be unable to perform better than someone else.

Let's say we lived in a world where I'm a worse live vocalist than Taylor Swift (we don't. She's still a pretty bad live vocalist). I would still be able to recognize whenever she screws up and have every right to criticize it.