Board Thread:Decisions/@comment-25763213-20171026132911/@comment-5392675-20171026142139

JustVladik4kides wrote:

Master Hydraffe wrote:

JustVladik4kides wrote:

Master Hydraffe wrote:

JustVladik4kides wrote:

Master Hydraffe wrote:

JustVladik4kides wrote:

Trexy821 wrote:

I have to agree with MH on this, and that we should just use the official song titles to avoid any confusion with finding the songs themselves. That would be even more confusing, since the title differs from the one which is in game. Also, the wiki would look more official if we would use that. For example, Nintendo wiki doesn't use "italian guy in a red cap" name for the mario page, because Mario is how the character is called in the game. Same with songs there. Except our songs don't exist in a vacuum -- they have official names, just like "Mario" is an official name for "Italian plumber video game character in a red cap". They have official names from labels, which released them, but not from Ubisoft. And those official names should take precedence over whatever Ubisoft calls them. But the game was made by Ubisoft and not by someone who made up those official names? That logic is unsound.

So in this hypothetical situation: If Ubisoft added a song called "ABC", but in the game it is listed as a completely different "DEF", we should name the article "DEF"? That does not make any sense. It does because that's how the song is credited in the game which this wiki is about. Ok, so "Side to Side", if its in-game name is "The Bicycle Song"... the article should be "The Bicycle Song".

That makes absolutely zero sense.