MJ Experience Crews

TheHashtagMan·1/5/2019 in Decisions

While editing pages from songs from Michael Jackson: The Experience which have more than two dancers (from the Wii and PS3 versions), I've seen multiple descriptions for their routines.

Some pages have Crew in the Mode section in the infobox, and other have Duet.

I think that Duet should be deleted from these pages because...it's not a duet. A duet is made out of two people.

I think Crew is a much better description and should be used for every song with three dancers in the game.

I also think it should be added as a section from the Trios page, because it is basically the same, but with the difference that P1 and P3 are exactly the same and have the same choreography.

The reason why the game only displays two dancers on the dancer selection screen instead of three is because P1 and P3 are exactly the same, so there is no need to put both of them. Thus, it shouldn't be considered a duet.

(sorry if I write poorly, im still learning)

Support = 3

Oppose = 0

Neutral = 1

(Edited by TheHashtagMan)

Saus the Seafish·1/5/2019

SupportMe

Of course Duet shouldn’t be written there, but I’m fine with Crew.

(Edited by Saus the Seafish)

AnimationIsAwesome·1/5/2019

NeutralMe

(Edited by AnimationIsAwesome)

TheChibiKing·1/6/2019

NeutralMe

If they feature 3 dancers, then they are Trios, not Crews (unless the game itself lists them as Crews).

(Edited by TheChibiKing)

Saus the Seafish·1/6/2019

TheChibiKing wrote: (unless the game itself lists them as Crews)

They list them as Crews.

(Edited by Saus the Seafish)

TheChibiKing·1/6/2019

Saus the Seafish wrote:

TheChibiKing wrote: (unless the game itself lists them as Crews)

They list them as Crews.

OK. SupportMe

then.

(Edited by TheChibiKing)

CAMERAwMUSTACHE·1/7/2019

SupportMe

Before JD2015-16 I would have been opposed to this. However, this is my reasoning now.

The game calls them “crews” or “dance crews” (which refers to a quartet in the main series) but the coach selection screen indicates a duet while the choreo shows a trio where P1/P3 are clones. Originally I would have said that this means it’s a duet. Now there’s songs like Hey Mama and New Face that are classified as trios with basically the same cloned backup dancers concept.

Long story short, if Hey Mama, New Face, etc., are trios so are the MJ ones. Whether we put “crew” or “trio” in the infobox is up for debate but it should have “trio” as the category and should link to trio in the infobox.

(Edited by CAMERAwMUSTACHE)

TheChibiKing·1/17/2019

More than 1 week has passed, but we only have 3 Supports. We need 7 more votes to make a decision.

(Edited by TheChibiKing)

What do you think?