The routine is performed by a dance crew of all males. All of the coaches are wearing tuxedos, with the only difference being the color of their shoes, bow ties, hairstyles, and the inside of their blazers.
P1 has short hair, and has pink accents.
P2 has curly pompadour hair, and has turquoise accents.
P3 has short straight hair, and red accents.
P4 has short curly hair, and purple accents.
The background is a white-and-pink paneled floor with squares. There are also stars and lights that flicker in rhythm. At some parts of the choreography, you can see sparks coming out from the cliffs.
What Makes You Beautiful has a Mashup which is available on all platforms on Just Dance 4.
A parody of What Makes You Beautiful appears in the Hebrew TV show מועדון לילה., where the original coaches are replaced by real-life recordings of three men and one woman in black suits and light blue shirts, whose faces are replaced by cartoony caricatures through CGI.
Oddly, the HUD is based off the one from Just Dance 2015.
Besides, the coach’s moves have been slightly slowed down while he fades away.
Puppet Master Mode
There is a glitch in the Puppet Master Mode: when the Extreme Version coach reappears at the end, the pictograms do not slide in until the dancer appears herself, resulting in the pictograms appearing all of a sudden.